Are Christians Required to Tithe?

Prefer to Listen?

Are Christians Required to Tithe?

No. I do not believe the New Testament requires Christians to give ten percent. But that does not mean Christians are free from the call to give.

The New Testament gives us something much broader than a fixed percentage. Christian giving is intentional, proportional, generous, sacrificial, and cheerful.

The real question is not whether Christians should give. Scripture is quite clear we should. The question is whether the ten-percent requirement given within Israel’s covenant continues as a binding rule for the post-resurrection Church.

I don’t believe it does.

What Was Tithing in the Old Testament?

The Old Testament biblical tithe served several concrete economic and religious purposes within Israel’s covenant system. The Mosaic Law established Israel as a theocracy. God ruled as the supreme authority and Israel’s civil and religious life were governed together under His covenant. The tribe of Levi was set apart by Yahweh to serve as a support structure to the priests’ religious leadership and maintenance of holy establishments (Num. 3:5–10). Because of their unique calling, God did not allow them to inherit a territorial allotment like the other tribes. God Himself was their inheritance (Num. 18:20).

However, the lack of land ownership created an obvious economic problem for the Levites. Israel was an agricultural community. Much of its economy depended on access to productive land for crops, vineyards, herds, and flocks. Because the Lord did not give the Levites a tribal land inheritance, yet also called them to religious service, God gave them the tithe of Israel “in return for the work they do while serving at the tent of meeting” (Num. 18:21).

Deuteronomy also describes a tithe that the Israelites were to bring to “the place the LORD your God will choose,” which later became Jerusalem, and eat there in God’s Presence. If the distance was too great to carry their harvests or a tenth of their herd or so on, they were to exchange that tenth of their prosperity for silver and spend that silver in the chosen place for food and drink. That food and drink would then be consumed in the chosen place (Deut. 14:22–27).

Every third year, Deuteronomy says the tithe of that year was to remain local and be allotted to the economic provision of the Levites, the foreigner, the fatherless, and the widows (Deut. 14:28–29). Each of these groups was at an economic disadvantage in Israel. The fatherless and widow lacked the traditional provider for the household. God also designed the inheritance laws to keep the land within Israel’s tribal system, with the exception of the tribe of Levi (Lev. 25:23; Num. 36:7–9), which also placed the resident foreigner outside Israel’s ordinary system of hereditary land allotment.

In other words, the Old Testament tithe system was more complex than a single ten-percent payment. Numbers assigns a tithe to the Levites for their service, while Deuteronomy also describes a tithe connected with worship and, every third year, provision for Levites, foreigners, orphans, and widows. Whether all of this describes different tithes or different uses of the tithe is debated, and the biblical texts do not spell out the relationship in a way that removes every difficulty.

What is clear, and more relevant for our purposes, is that the tithe was embedded in the economic and worship structure of Israel’s covenant life. The tithe served as support for the Levites, participated in worship before God, and provided for people at an economic disadvantage. It was never merely a religious percentage detached from Israel’s actual social structure. It funded service, worship, and provision within the covenant community.

Objection! Abraham Tithed Before the Law

Once.

We have one confirmable instance when Abraham gave a tenth of his prosperity to Melchizedek, king of Salem, in Genesis 14:20. This is entirely different from the tithing system ordained in the Mosaic Law. That was an ongoing system of required tithes. Abraham only gave this tithe once.

We also have Jacob’s commitment to ongoing tithing as part of a vow concerning God’s continued provision (Gen. 28:20–22). But notice how this is also different from the later tithing system. Jacob says that if God remains with him, protects him, provides for him, and brings him safely home, then the LORD will be his God and Jacob will give Him a tenth. This is a personal vow, not a command imposed on everyone.

We don’t even know how Jacob intended to give this tithe. Matter of fact, we don’t even know if Jacob actually followed up on this promise. The Bible records the commitment, not the execution.

There is no recorded command to tithe between Jacob’s commitment and the Mosaic Law. But there was an entire history in between. If God wanted the tithe established as an obligation before the Mosaic Law, where did He command such a thing? He never once did. The tithe only became obligatory after God gave Israel the Mosaic Law.

So if we want to argue tithing precedes the Law in order to establish it remains obligatory after the Law, then we first have to show the tithe was obligatory before the Law.

And it wasn’t.

Before the Mosaic Law, the biblical examples we have are voluntary acts of honoring God, not evidence of a universal ten-percent command.

Does Malachi 3 Require Christians to Tithe?

Malachi 3:8–10 is often used by modern teachers to support a New Testament obligatory tithe. In the passage, God accuses post-exile Judah of robbing Him by withholding their tithes and offerings. The result is a lack of sufficient food available for the priests and Levites. Therefore, the Lord declares the nation to be under a curse.

The Lord then challenges them to test His provision if they restore the tithes and offerings. He promises to pour out an overabundant blessing, as well as prevent crop pests and the dropping of pre-ripe fruit. In other words, He’s promising to provide more than what they’ve given. They have no need to fear lack.

That blessing-and-curse framework matters because modern teachers often lift the warning from Malachi and apply it directly to Christians. New Testament believers are told they are robbing God, or even placing themselves under a curse, if they do not tithe. But before we apply that warning to the Church, we have to ask who God was actually speaking to and under what covenant.

In the context, God is speaking of a specific curse on a specific people group. These people are under covenantal agreement to provide these tithes and offerings and were pre-warned of a curse if they failed to honor the covenant (Deut. 28:15–68). However, they were also promised a blessing if they should obey the Law of Moses (Deut. 28:1–14).

Neither the curse nor the blessing of Deuteronomy 28 applies to the New Testament Christian. It was a specific covenant to a specific people. Likewise, neither the curse nor the blessings proclaimed in Malachi 3 are relevant to the Christian as covenantal obligations or promises. It is a specific blessing and a specific curse active toward a specific people and relevant to specific land.

If we wanted to apply Malachi to Christians, we would need a Scriptural bridge that allows us to do so. Something in the Bible has to link the New Testament Christian to Old Testament blessings and curses. We do not have that. We actually have a sort of opposite. Christians are warned against being under the yoke of the Law, described as “a yoke of slavery” (Gal. 5:1). Paul blatantly warns the Church of Galatia:

“…if you let yourselves be circumcised, Christ will be of no value to you at all. Again I declare to every man who lets himself be circumcised that he is obligated to obey the whole law. You who are trying to be justified by the law have been alienated from Christ; you have fallen away from grace.”

Galatians 5:2–4

We really need to pause and think about what Paul is saying. To place oneself under one requirement of the Law as an obligation for righteousness enslaves us to the whole Law, which alienates us from Christ such that He is of no value to us, and removes us from grace.

If we were to apply the obligation of tithes and offerings to our lives, we are chaining ourselves to that which cannot save us (Gal. 2:16) and, more alarmingly, reliance on the Law for righteousness results in a failure to be justified before God (Gal. 3:11). We are saved by grace, and only by grace (Eph. 2:8–9).

In the Parable of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector, Jesus presents a man, the Pharisee, who boasts to God of his fasting and tithing. Then Jesus presents a man, the tax collector, who refused to so much as gaze toward heaven and cries out for mercy, for he knows he has nothing to boast of. It is not the tither who walked away justified, but the one who declared himself a sinner.

Don’t get me wrong. I am not saying it is a problem to tithe.

The tithe is actually an excellent starting point when evaluating wise giving.

The problem with the Pharisee is faith in his own works, not tithing itself. I am saying that teaching tithing as obligatory on account of such Scriptures as Malachi 3 is reading theology into Scripture, rather than pulling theology out of Scripture. To obligate oneself to tithing for the sake of grudging obedience rather than genuine generosity is to bow to the Law and neglect grace.

Does Hebrews 7 Require Christians to Tithe?

Because Abraham tithed (once) to Melchizedek, and Hebrews 7 ties Melchizedek to Christ, some scholars argue that connection carries the tithe into the Christian Church. I would argue the correlation means the exact opposite. Now that we are aware that Abraham’s tithe was not obligatory, but voluntary, we cannot use that voluntary act by itself to establish an obligatory Christian tithe.

What sense is there to say Abraham volunteered his tithe to Melchizedek and because Christ is likened to Melchizedek, then we are obligated to tithe, ironically, not to Christ but to the Christian Church?

The Church is not equivalent to Christ, Beloved.

So even if we wanted to argue that Melchizedek is correlated to Christ and, therefore, we should do as Abraham did, we cannot make up an entire argumentative bridge that says, Melchizedek is correlated to Christ and Christ is the Head of the Body of Christ and therefore, tithing to the Church is tithing to Christ and oh, by the way, we are going to make this tithing required even though Abraham’s was voluntary.

This is what the well-loved Alistair Begg calls “getting tied up in your theological underpants.”

Our conclusions must come from Scripture. Scripture cannot be interpreted by our conclusions. There is nothing in Hebrews 7 that intelligibly says Christ required a tithe.

Speaking of…

Didn’t Jesus Tell People to Tithe?

Let’s go to Matthew 23:23. Jesus is in the middle of a massive rebuke-session to the religious leaders when He says:

“Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You give a tenth of your spices, mint, dill and cumin. But you have neglected the more weighty matters of the law, justice, mercy and faithfulness. You should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former.”

Contextually, Jesus is dealing with the hypocrisy of the religious leaders. He begins His rather inflammatory message with a warning to do what the leaders teach, but don’t follow what they do. The leaders are willing to burden the people but not willing to help with those burdens. Throughout the entire chapter of Matthew 23, Jesus calls them blind guides, whitewashed tombs, pretty on the outside and dead on the inside, snakes, and refers to them as hypocrites six times.

In other words, this is not a lesson on the principles of tithing, Beloved.

When Jesus condemns these individuals for tithing, yet neglecting “justice, mercy and faithfulness” (Matt. 23:23), He is making a statement about the state of their spirituality. When He says they are to tithe and practice justice, mercy and faithfulness, He is speaking to religious leaders subject to the Law of Moses. These are not Christians, and that matters.

Christians are not subject to the Law of Moses, but to the Spirit of Christ (Rom. 7:4–6). If we want to know what Jesus wants His followers, Christians, to do with their money, then we must look at verses that address specifically that.

In Luke 12:33 Jesus teaches:

“Sell your possessions and give to the poor. Provide purses for yourselves that will not wear out, a treasure in heaven that will never fail, where no thief comes near and no moth destroys.”

Notice He does not say how much to sell and how much to give. In the context, Christ’s lesson is not to restrain our giving because we are worried about tomorrow’s provision. We are to trust the Father to provide, seek His kingdom, and give generously rather than hoarding out of fear.

You see, I would suggest the system of tithing had a weakness that the New Testament principles of cheerful giving correct. We see it quite clearly in Christ’s observation of the impoverished widow. The rich gave offerings of great amounts while the widow gave only two coins worth nearly nothing. Jesus said, “They all gave out of their wealth; but she, out of her poverty, put in everything, all she had to live on” (Mk. 12:44).

Let’s take this a bit more modern.

Let’s say a rich billionaire earns a million a month and tithes $100,000. Every month. That’s quite impressive, isn’t it?

Now we have a widow who lives on $1,000 a month. The widow tithes $100. Every month. The widow has $900 to live on…the billionaire has…at the minimum? What, a billion?

Who barely even noticed the loss of the tithe and who is burdened by it?

Yet the billionaire pats himself on the back for giving so generously.

But who was really more generous?

The math imbalance is quite horrific when put into that perspective, isn’t it?

New Testament giving fixes that imbalance.

Tithing in the New Testament

In 2 Corinthians 9:6–7, Paul gives a precious slice of wisdom:

“Remember this: Whoever sows sparingly will also reap sparingly, and whoever sows generously will also reap generously. Each of you should give what you have decided in your heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.”

That is the New Testament standard of giving summed up with a lovely pink bow. We are to give what our hearts cheerfully decide to give.

This does not mean we give what is most comfortable to give, which would be absolutely nothing for me. There is always a voice in the back of my head screeching, I can use that! That’s not what Paul is talking about when he says not to give reluctantly or under compulsion. He is talking about giving because we feel we have to rather than we want to.

I can desire to give 5, 10 or 90% of such and such paycheck and be perfectly okay with deciding to ignore the screeching in the back of my head. I actually recommend ignoring the screeching. Wisdom will not screech. Wisdom will review the whole situation and select the most loving decision.

I do think there is a principle of New Testament giving that we need to be very mindful of. When encouraging the Corinthian church to give in 2 Corinthians 8:13–15, Paul says:

“Our desire is not that others might be relieved while you are hard pressed, but that there might be equality. At the present time your plenty will supply what they need, so that in turn their plenty will supply what you need. The goal is equality, as it is written: ‘The one who gathered much did not have too much, and the one who gathered little did not have too little.’”

In other words, Paul is suggesting an economic balance. Not of a specific number, but one of communal wisdom. Those with plenty should supply where there is need. And when those in need have more than is sufficient, they should give in turn. The goal is that one person’s abundance supplies another person’s need rather than some believers having plenty while others within the community remain in genuine need.

This is not to mean the rich should support those who have been lazy. Paul is quite firm that “the one who is unwilling to work shall not eat” (2 Thess. 3:10). It also does not mean those who are poor should be content not to give in some wise way. Remember the poor widow Jesus commends for giving two tiny coins, everything she had to live on (Mk. 12:42–44). It means each is to give according to their means, but each is still encouraged to give.

Being a cheerful giver also implies the correct motive.

If we give because we want to be blessed, we are not giving cheerfully, but selfishly. But if we give because we see a genuine need for provision, and we desire to contribute to that need, then we can give while trusting God with our own provision.

Thoughts for Those With Abundance

Let us who have an abundance be wise not to hoard on the principle that we “worked hard for this.” It is God who gives the ability to earn wealth (Deut. 8:18). In addition, it is the Almighty who distributes resources (1 Sam. 2:7).

When I hear someone say, that person worked hard for that money, I personally tend to think, a janitor works hard, too, and God gave the janitor the hands with which to work that hard.

But when we do give generously, let us remember a wise tidbit from a very wealthy king:

“But who am I, and who are my people, that we should be able to give as generously as this? Everything comes from you, and we have given you only what comes from your hand” (1 Chr. 29:14).

And, Beloved, when I say those with abundance, I do not mean just those with a six-digit income. Abundance is relative. Many of us have access to comforts and resources that go well beyond our basic needs, even if we would never describe ourselves as wealthy.

Supporting the Economy

Another thing for us to consider is economic contribution. I used to believe I had to give away every spare penny I had and neglect to buy nice things for myself.

That’s not automatically wisdom.

An economy thrives on a healthy balance of buying and selling. So one way of using money for the good of others is to support jobs. Farmers markets are a great example of this. There you will find people who are just trying to responsibly make a living. That is a healthy and wise place to bless self and others. Buying a necklace or some muffins treats you and/or a loved one, but it also helps another person purchase eggs without asking for charity.

I believe God smiles on being intentional with that sort of wise spending as much as He smiles upon giving to those who cannot give something in return. Giving to someone in need is not the only way our money can benefit another person. Wise spending can also help someone earn an honest living, support a family, and remain economically independent.

Should Christians Give to Their Local Church?

I would give a resounding yes…with some caveats that would definitely make some church leaders a little cranky.

A church’s ordinary physical needs, such as meeting space, utilities, and maintenance, and church leaders whose ministry requires enough of their time that outside employment would interfere with that work are unquestionably worthy of Christian generosity (1 Cor. 9:9–10; 1 Tim. 5:17–18). I personally think the median income of the congregation can be a useful reference point when deciding what constitutes reasonable pastoral compensation, though circumstances will differ considerably from church to church.

For many Christians, the local church will naturally receive a substantial portion of their giving because it is where they are taught, gathered, cared for, and served. That makes sense. But I do not think that means every dollar set aside for Christian generosity must remain there.

With that being said…I do believe many a local church is guilty of accepting more money than necessary and spending the excess unwisely. I’m speaking from my own thoughts here, but I will give an example.

Several years ago, I left a church for quite a few reasons, but financial management was a huge factor. We’ll call this church “Laodicea.”

Laodicea drew my attention to finances when my favorite program of packing gift boxes for impoverished children was cut off from funding. The church decided it was investing too much money into this program, about 90% of which came from congregant-directed funds. The cost to the church’s general fund was about $1,500 a month.

For some churches, that is quite a bit.

But Laodicea, as I found out, ran on a 5-million-dollar annual budget.

I also found out the church spent $12,000 a month on donuts and $100,000 a year on storage for the pastor’s books.

When I asked about the donuts, the administrative pastor raised his brow and said, “Have you looked at the budget we are working with?”

In other words…we have money to spend.

But not enough money to spend on impoverished kids.

It was my opinion that this church was not a wise location for my donated money.

The point I am trying to make is a church that has the wealth to spend frivolously, as defined by prayerful wisdom, is not automatically the highest-priority place for every dollar of our generosity. I, personally, would not allocate all of my generosity funds to that church.

It is my opinion that there are too many Christian charities out there that are scraping by, praying to God for provision to keep the lights on as they do the good works of the Lord, for us to contribute to unnecessary church luxury. If there were no hungry children in the world, and every Christian charity was sufficiently funded for their work, I would not care about the donuts.

But children are starving, therefore I care about the donuts.

Some may object: but aren’t those donuts supporting local jobs?

So the question is, do we fund the gift boxes to impoverished kids or the local bakery?

Well, the gift boxes are being used to spread the Gospel to these kids. They have to hear the Gospel before they get their box and the results are incredibly fruitful. The local bakery gets a bigger paycheck that helps keep their lights on.

I know which way my conscience tugs.

This is where prayer needs to replace our own assumptions. The Christian is free, Beloved. Churches are allowed to buy donuts. But we need to be aware of how our money is used and be willing to put conditions on its usage if necessary. Where we are unsure, we take our questions to prayer and seek wisdom from the Body of Christ.

This is how I handle my own giving and stewardship budget, just as an example. My family has a set amount put aside for giving and intentional Christian spending every month. A good portion of that goes to my current church. I pay attention to the church finances to make sure there is no unfunded need in our church that I should prioritize.

The rest I hold in a bank account to be used in different ways. It depends on what crosses my path that month. I may give some to missionaries we support, or some to Christian charities I care about. Other portions go to my own ministry bills and even my Bible education and journaling supplies.

Spiritual growth matters because the more I grow spiritually, the more I can help others grow spiritually.

Christian products like commentaries, study software, journaling Bibles, or even pens from Christian companies matter to me because the more we support worthwhile Christian businesses and products, the more of those resources remain available to help others on their own journey.

The idea is that I have set aside a specific amount of money that I consider holy to the Lord. My rule of thumb is to be extremely mindful that I am using this money in a way that honors God’s work on the earth. Some of it is charitable giving, and some of it is stewardship spending that supports ministry, spiritual growth, and Christian work.

What I am trying to show is the idea of setting aside an automatic and obligatory 10% to go only to our local church is an extremely limited and, sometimes unwise, way of interacting with generosity and financial stewardship.

The Church is the Body of Christ, Beloved. Not a single organization that meets every Sunday.

If we care about the needs of the Church, then we need to consider the needs of the Church as a whole.

Where That Leaves Us

Are Christians required to tithe to church organizations? No.

Are Christians required to hand over a particular percentage of their income? No.

We are free, Beloved. But Christian freedom does not release us from the obligation to love. We are called to care about the needs of the Church and the needs of our neighbors. If we see our neighbor hungry, then our love should drive us to give them food. If we see our local church is struggling to keep the lights on for the building where we meet, our love for the Church Body should drive us to contribute to the bills as we can.

The obligation is love, not a percentage.

Love is generous because love wants what is good for our neighbor. Sometimes that means sacrificing what we want in order to give them what they need. Sometimes it means buying what appeals to us in an intentional effort to bless the work of others. Generosity can be contributing to someone’s need or contributing to someone’s business.

Just remember, “It is more blessed to give than to receive” (Acts 20:35).


All Scripture quotations are from the New International Version (NIV).  

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *