Slavery in the Bible: What the Bible Actually Says About Slavery

Does the Bible Condone Slavery?

Slavery in the Bible is authorized. I cannot, and should not, dance around it. And honestly, I think God is severely misrepresented when Christians try to.

Leviticus 25:44–46 is unflinchingly blatant:

“Your male and female slaves are to come from the nations around you; from them you may buy slaves. You may also buy some of the temporary residents living among you and members of their clans born in your country, and they will become your property. You can bequeath them to your children as inherited property and can make them slaves for life, but you must not rule over your fellow Israelites ruthlessly.”

There it is. The Bible supports slavery.

Yikes.

Let’s look at scholarship’s favorite defense. All slavery in the Bible was temporary indentured servitude. A way to pay off debt.

Thank you, scholarship, for that completely inaccurate analysis.

Now don’t get me wrong. Some of slavery in the Bible was indentured servanthood. Deuteronomy 15:12–18 is an excellent example where the Hebrew serves six years, then must be released the seventh. The master is then commanded to offer provision for the servant upon his or her departure.

Let’s try their other provided defense: Leviticus 25 only applies to prisoners of war. That’s supposed to be easier to swallow? And again, completely inaccurate. Buying from the non-Jewish residents is not war language.

So yeah, we’re still at “yikes.”

But before you throw out the baby with the bathwater, we have some investigating to do. 

What did ownership of another person mean under Israelite law, what limits did God place upon that ownership, and does the institution itself establish a contradiction with God’s goodness?

Slavery in the Bible does exist. The Bible authorizes slavery. Just not in the way you’re probably thinking of.

Scripture Overview

  • Exodus 21:2–11 — Israelites may buy Hebrew servants, and a Hebrew servant serves six years and goes free in the seventh without paying for his release. If he has a wife when he becomes a servant, she is freed along with him. If the master provides him a wife, and she bears him children, the woman and children continue to belong to the master and only the man goes free. I actually think this is one of the hardest passages to understand among the slavery laws in the Bible. I’m not going to comment on it because I do not understand it. That doesn’t stop me from evaluating the slavery passages as a whole.
  • Exodus 21:20–21 — A master may beat a male or female slave with a rod but is to be punished if the slave dies due to the beating. If the slave survives a day or two, the master is not subject to that punishment because the slave is described as his property or money. Another very hard verse to understand.
  • Exodus 21:26–27 — If a slave owner causes permanent bodily injury, illustrated by destroying an eye or knocking out a tooth, the slave is to be released as compensation for the injury.
  • Leviticus 25:39–43 — An impoverished Israelite may enter service but is not to be treated as an ordinary slave. He serves until the Year of Jubilee.
  • Leviticus 25:44–46 — Israelites may acquire male and female slaves from the surrounding nations and from foreigners living among them. These slaves may be held permanently and passed on as an inheritance.
  • Leviticus 25:47–55 — An Israelite who becomes poor and sells himself to a wealthy foreign resident retains rights of redemption and must be released at Jubilee if not redeemed earlier.
  • Deuteronomy 15:12–18 — Hebrew servants are to be freed after six years of service and sent away with generous provisions from the master’s own livestock, threshing floor, and winepress.
  • Deuteronomy 23:15–16 — An escaped slave is not to be returned to the master. The slave may live wherever he chooses among Israel and must not be oppressed.
  • Jeremiah 34:8–22 — God judges Judah after the people release Hebrew slaves and then seize them again and force them back into slavery.

A major takeaway from this review is that God allowed slavery, there were multiple types of slavery, and there were laws to regulate how that slavery was implemented. None of these passages can be treated as doctrine independent of the others. Both the immediate context and the larger legal context have to be considered together.

What Does Leviticus 25 Say About Slavery?

“Your male and female slaves are to come from the nations around you; from them you may buy slaves. You may also buy some of the temporary residents living among you and members of their clans born in your country, and they will become your property. You can bequeath them to your children as inherited property and can make them slaves for life, but you must not rule over your fellow Israelites ruthlessly” (Lev. 25:44–46).

This is the hotbed of controversy regarding the question, does the Bible endorse slavery?

And I have hemmed and hawed over this. Do I say the Bible permits but does not condone? “Permits” seems too weak. “Condones” seems too strong. Can we actually rule out the word “endorse”?

Ugh.

The question seems to be, does God approve of slavery or does He merely tolerate it?

Again, ugh.

I haven’t found Scripture to warrant “approval” but Leviticus 25 rules out mere tolerance. God really could have told the Israelites, no slavery other than indentured servitude for the purpose of paying off debt.

Sounds good to me.

But: Go ahead. You can have slaves.

Yikes.

Why?

I don’t know, and I haven’t found an explanation I find acceptable.

Slaves as property in the Bible?

Yeah, it’s a real thing. I genuinely think God was okay with humans as property. Not, slavery is awesome! Nor, I’ll deal with it until I can eliminate it. But: Yeah, okay. You can have human slaves.

Don’t stone me.

I’m going to make an argument that the kind of slavery God authorized, administered His way, is radically different from humanity’s history of slave treatment, but I cannot erase the “acceptable” part of this sentence.

I can’t.

And, ducks stones, maybe I shouldn’t.

Why?

Because whether God finds slavery, administered His way, acceptable is directly correlated with His goodness. If God is good, then His decisions are good. I don’t have to understand His decisions to know that they arise from a place of goodness.

I don’t trust my understanding.

I trust God’s character.

Did the Bible Treat Slaves as Less Human?

First of all, what does it even mean to treat anyone as “human”? I have no idea. The philosophy on that one would require books. Plural. I’m not volunteering for the task.

What can we know?

God is protective of all humans. Plural. We are all made in the image of God. Specifically, the Lord explicitly warns against the murder of a human in a way He does not seem equally concerned about the killing of animals (Gen. 9:3–6). Whether a human or animal kills a human, God will require an accounting. And He ties His reasoning to humans being made in the image of God.

But notice what He does not say. He does not say, you may not have slaves as property because they are made in my image. And I think the term property or the idea of ownership has a well-earned horrifying taste in the mouth.

But I’m going to argue that the biblically acceptable form of ownership is tied much more closely to a permanent servant to loving master relationship than it is to a less-than-human slave to oppressive master sort of relationship.

Calling it permanent servanthood does not erase the fact that Scripture describes the person as property. I am using the term to describe the kind of relationship the surrounding laws produce, not to replace the word slavery.

Let’s detour to Leviticus 19:33–34:

“When a foreigner resides among you in your land, do not mistreat them. The foreigner residing among you must be treated as your native-born. Love them as yourself, for you were foreigners in Egypt. I am the Lord your God.”

Where does it say, unless that foreigner is a slave?

It doesn’t.

I would argue, I believe quite easily, that the golden rule applies to slaves. Do to others what you would have them do to you (Matt. 7:12).

So there’s a few rules we can pull from Scripture that paint a very different image of biblical slavery than that based on oppression:

  1. Do not mistreat your slaves.
  2. Love them as yourself.
  3. If you cause permanent injury, you must let the slave go free as compensation for the injury (Exod. 21:26–27).
  4. Hebrew servants are to be released after six years of service under Exodus 21:2 and Deuteronomy 15:12. Leviticus 25:39–43 separately requires an impoverished Israelite serving another Israelite to be released at the Year of Jubilee.
  5. You may not beat a slave to death, but you may beat them (Exod. 21:20–21). I have a whole section dedicated to this one, don’t worry.
  6. A female sold as a servant and brought into a marital relationship must maintain that marital relationship and be given relational rights. She cannot be dismissed. This protects her from agreeing to a marriage but then being used and tossed away. And no, this does not mean an owner can forcefully marry her. Scripture does not treat sexual access to a woman as something a man may simply take by force, nor does it give slave women an exception from those protections (cf. Deut. 22:25–29).
  7. You may not retrieve a runaway slave (Deut. 23:15–16).

What Does the Bible Say About Runaway Slaves?

Let’s talk about that last rule because I think it really matters.

“If a slave has taken refuge with you, do not hand them over to their master. Let them live among you wherever they like and in whatever town they choose. Do not oppress them” (Deut. 23:15–16).

Many scholars, for some reason, take this to mean that if a foreign slave takes refuge in Israel, then Israel must allow the slave to live in Israel as any other foreigner. That interpretation generally understands the passage as describing a foreign slave fleeing into Israel. But the text itself does not say foreign slave, foreign master, or foreign country. There is nothing in the surrounding context to require that restriction.

The problem with that interpretation is that it excludes Israel’s own slaves and I firmly believe it should not. Think about it. Foreigners can run away to you but your own slaves cannot run away?

That would be hypocritical.

No. I think the far more accurate interpretation of Deuteronomy 23:15–16 is that any slave who runs away is not to be forced back into slavery. And no, I do not think we should picture God allowing a slave owner to chain their slave somewhere so that they cannot escape. That would negate the whole point of the verse.

That does not mean that if the slave is indentured because of debt, then the debt is nullified. The passage tells us the slave cannot be returned to the master. It does not tell us that an underlying debt simply disappears, so I don’t think we can assume that it does.

Where can the slave run away to?

Quite clearly anywhere. They could run to a friend’s house down the street and the owner must respect that, if my reading of this passage is correct. The owner cannot force the slave to stay in servitude. That, I believe, is the entire point.

What does this mean?

It means the slave must be loved well enough that he or she desires to stay with the master. If the master fails to do this, and the slave runs away, then the master must accept the consequences of losing his right to that individual’s servitude.

Which takes us directly to our next topic.

Does the Bible Allow Masters to Beat Slaves?

“Anyone who beats their male or female slave with a rod must be punished if the slave dies as a direct result, but they are not to be punished if the slave recovers after a day or two, since the slave is their property” (Exod. 21:20–21).

While this verse is difficult, I don’t think it’s as difficult as some perspectives make it out to be. Remember, the master must love the slave as himself and he must treat the slave so well the slave does not run away.

I don’t think the point here is that a master can beat their slave so severely that they die three days later, but not so severely that they die within the first two days. The NIV uses the word “recovers,” although other translations render the wording more like “survives” or “stands.” So I don’t want my entire argument hanging on that English word. But neither do I think this passage should be isolated from the laws immediately surrounding it. Exodus 21:26–27 makes permanent bodily injury grounds for release.

In other words, the master is allowed to discipline the slave with the same instrument Scripture also associates with the physical discipline of children (Prov. 13:24; Prov. 22:15). I am not saying a slave-master relationship is identical to a parent-child relationship. I am saying Scripture recognizes a category of physical discipline with a rod that is distinguishable from destructive violence. But they have to do it in such a way that does not qualify as mistreatment and the slave does not want to run away. They also cannot cause permanent damage without forfeiting the slave.

That really, really limits a master’s options.

If the master goes too far, however, and kills the slave, then the master is to be punished. And I think that when God says punished, He’s not saying, give him a few lashes and send him on his way. The text does not tell us exactly what that punishment is, so I cannot assign one with confidence. But the fact that punishment is required means ownership does not excuse the slave’s death. The master is still accountable for the life of the person he owns.

This is why I think that authorized slavery in the Bible should be thought of more in terms of permanent servanthood than our modern concept of slavery. In many of the oppressive slave systems familiar to us from history, the master may, without consequence:

  • Retrieve a runaway slave and punish the slave for running away
  • Mistreat/oppress the slave
  • Rape the slave
  • Inflict forms of violence that biblical law places under restriction

In Bible verses about slavery, we see God restricting slavery to:

  • Loving treatment
  • Highly restrained discipline
  • Justice for punishment that ends in death
  • Freedom to run away
  • Freedom for permanent damage caused to the slave
  • Lifelong protection for female slaves who agree to marriage
  • Protection from rape
  • Release of Hebrew slaves after a set amount of time

In other words, the world’s view of slavery circles around oppression. God’s view of slavery circles around an authorized relationship of service governed by love, justice, and limits on the master’s power. In the case of permanent slavery, I think the picture that emerges is much closer to permanent service within a loving relationship than to the oppressive ownership we normally picture when we hear the word slavery.

Why Were Israelite and Foreign Slaves Treated Differently?

Let’s look at the actual verses governing this concept:

“‘If any of your fellow Israelites become poor and sell themselves to you, do not make them work as slaves. They are to be treated as hired workers or temporary residents among you; they are to work for you until the Year of Jubilee. Then they and their children are to be released, and they will go back to their own clans and to the property of their ancestors. Because the Israelites are my servants, whom I brought out of Egypt, they must not be sold as slaves. Do not rule over them ruthlessly, but fear your God… for the Israelites belong to me as servants. They are my servants, whom I brought out of Egypt. I am the Lord your God’” (Lev. 25:39–43, 55, emphasis mine).

There are two things I want to interact with here.

First, there are things these passages clearly teach:

  • Israelites were not allowed to be treated as slaves, but as hired workers or temporary residents.
  • Israelite indentured servants are to be released at the Year of Jubilee.
  • They are not to be ruled over “ruthlessly.”
  • Israelites belong to Yahweh.
  • The reason they are given a different treatment status from foreign slaves is because they belong to Yahweh, who brought them out of Egypt.

Here’s what I think is actually going on here. Feel free to agree or disagree.

God redeemed Israel out of Egypt. Therefore, the Israelites already have a master. They belong to God. They are already in an agreed-upon relationship of permanent service to their Master (Deut. 29:10–15; Exod. 24:3–8).

So for them to belong in permanent service to God while simultaneously belonging to a human master in a permanent relationship of service could, I believe, be considered a form of double dipping.

Let’s say, hypothetically, I owned a slave. But then the slave went off and borrowed money from the neighbor that he could not repay. I may allow the slave to serve that neighbor for a set period of time to pay off the debt, but I may not be willing to hand over ownership of the slave. I tell the neighbor, you may borrow him, but I want him back after six years.

That’s far more fair to everyone all around.

A foreign slave sold to Israel or gained through warfare has not necessarily entered that same covenant relationship in which Yahweh claims Israel as His redeemed servants. Under this theory, there is no competing permanent covenant claim of the same kind.

So the implication here, as I see it, is not that the Israelites are exempt from permanent service. It is that they are already in permanent service. They cannot, or should not, have two permanent masters.

But again, that is just my theory.

The clear reason given for Israelites not to become permanent slaves is because they already belong to Yahweh.

Could a Foreigner Become Part of Israel?

Let’s look at Exodus 12:43–49 because I think it’s quite important:

“The Lord said to Moses and Aaron, ‘These are the regulations for the Passover meal:

No foreigner may eat it. Any slave you have bought may eat it after you have circumcised him, but a temporary resident or a hired worker may not eat it.

It must be eaten inside the house; take none of the meat outside the house. Do not break any of the bones. The whole community of Israel must celebrate it.

A foreigner residing among you who wants to celebrate the Lord’s Passover must have all the males in his household circumcised; then he may take part like one born in the land. No uncircumcised male may eat it. The same law applies both to the native-born and to the foreigner residing among you” (Exod. 12:43–49, emphasis mine).

God’s provision for access to the covenantal relationship was not restricted to ethnic Israelites. Foreigners could enter into Israel’s covenant life rather than remaining permanently outside it.

The book of Ruth is rather telling for this because Ruth comes from the Moabites, a nation God is particularly displeased with (Deut. 23:3–6), yet Ruth is accepted because she has made Israel’s God her God and Israel’s people her people and submits herself to the judgment of the Lord (Ruth 1:16–17).

So when we combine Exodus 12’s provision for entrance into the covenant community of Israel with the Leviticus 25 slavery regulations, we can make a very reasonable inference: a foreign slave has a provision for entering the same covenant community that gives Israelites their distinct status under Leviticus 25. Exodus 12:44 specifically applies Passover participation after circumcision to purchased slaves.

The very practice of eating the Passover meal is linked to God redeeming (delivering) Israel out of Egypt (Exod. 12:27). So when God says, you can eat that meal, God is saying, I’m applying that redemption to you.

Once that redemption is applied to an individual, that person enters covenant relationship with Yahweh and is treated “like one born in the land” (Exod. 12:48).

And that matters enormously for slavery.

Leviticus 25 says Israelites cannot be permanently enslaved because they are Yahweh’s servants whom He brought out of Egypt (Lev. 25:42, 55). Exodus 12 allows a foreign slave to enter into the covenant memorial of that same redemption.

So once the foreign slave enters that redeemed covenant community, the permanent-foreigner category no longer applies to him. He now shares the covenant status upon which Israel’s protection from permanent slavery is based.

Did God Care Whether Slave Owners Followed These Laws?

In the Jeremiah 34 slavery passage, the violation of God’s slavery regulations is placed under severe judgment. God sends word through Jeremiah for Judah to release all Hebrew slaves because they and their ancestors had not obeyed God’s requirement to release Hebrew servants after six years (Jer. 34:14).

So the people heeded God’s word and released all their Hebrew slaves. But then they changed their minds and forced them back into slavery.

God identifies this reversal as a violation of His covenant and pronounces judgment upon Judah. He declares they will “fall by the sword, plague, and famine” (Jer. 34:17).

Judgment does fall on Judah, and Jerusalem in particular, and those who survive are carried into Babylon, where Scripture says they “became servants” to the Babylonian king and his successors (2 Chron. 36:20).

So when we are asking, what does the Bible say about slavery, we must give consideration to how God reacts when His regulations on slavery are violated. The violation of His servants’ freedom was serious enough to be explicitly included among the grounds for judgment. And there is a striking reversal in what follows: the people who forced their fellow Hebrews back into servitude are themselves carried into Babylonian servitude. God later condemns Babylon because, although He had given His people into Babylon’s hand, Babylon “showed them no mercy” (Isa. 47:6).

Why Didn’t God Abolish Slavery?

Let’s look at the abominations of historical slavery once again. Masters had the right to:

  • Retrieve a runaway slave and punish the slave for running away
  • Mistreat/oppress the slave
  • Rape the slave
  • Inflict forms of violence that biblical law places under restriction

It makes moral sense to abolish such a system. There is no legal chance at freedom, no refuge for the runaway slave, nor justice for rape victims or violations of restrained discipline. There is nothing humane about that.

But biblically authorized slavery carries a radically different set of moral conditions. It is a relationship of service governed by loving treatment, justice for victims, limits on the master’s power, and, under Deuteronomy 23:15–16, freedom to seek refuge and not be forcibly returned.

And when I call some of this slavery “permanent,” I mean there is no automatic release date attached to the relationship. I do not mean the master has an absolute right to force the slave to remain for life.

I have to be honest; military service is both legal and widely considered humane, yet contracted servicemembers do not have the freedom to change their minds and walk away. We therefore already recognize that a binding relationship of service is not automatically inhumane merely because the person cannot independently end it.

Do you see the point I am trying to make here?

Much of our horror at slavery is tied to the cruelty, coercion, sexual exploitation, violence, and absolute control historically associated with it. But what if we take the inhumane part out of the picture? What if we replace it with a loving relationship where the servant has the right to walk away?

How many of us would still call that slavery?

So maybe God didn’t abolish slavery in the Bible, but He abolished the features that made historical slavery so horrifying to most of us in the first place.

Does this solve the problem for people who object to the idea of ownership of another human being?

No.

But the very good God of the universe does not seem to share that problem, and He does not apologize for it.

What About Slavery in the New Testament?

Let’s look at a few verses:

  • Ephesians 6:5–9 — Slaves are told to respect and obey their masters while masters are told to treat them without threats, remembering that both master and slave answer to the same Master in heaven.
  • Colossians 3:22–4:1 — Slaves are told to obey their earthly masters, while masters are commanded to provide what is right and fair because they also have a Master in heaven.
  • Philemon — The master is told to accept Onesimus as “no longer a slave, but better than a slave, as a dear brother” (Philem. 16).
  • 1 Timothy 1:10 — Those who enslave or traffic human beings are listed among those acting contrary to sound doctrine.
  • Galatians 3:28 — “There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.” Slave and free share the same standing in Christ.

So while the New Testament never says, “slavery is wrong” or “slavery should be abolished,” it provides guidance that is consistent with God’s Old Testament regulations on slavery, with a major distinction that slave and free stand together as one within the Body of Christ (Gal. 3:28).

Further, I think it is even more significant to point out a unique phenomenon among New Testament writers. Several passages show Christians referring to themselves as, or being referred to as, servants and slaves of Christ (see verses like Rom. 1:1; 1 Cor. 7:22–23; Eph. 6:6).

I think of it this way. In the Old Testament, Israelites entered a permanent covenant relationship as servants of God. They belonged to God. In the same way, in the New Testament, Christians enter a new covenant that establishes them as permanent servants of Christ (cf. Heb. 8; Lk. 22:20).

I am trying to highlight that biblical writers seem to use the language of permanent servanthood and slavery interchangeably in describing belonging to God and Christ. I cannot find a verse that shows the New Testament writers considered slavery, i.e. belonging to another as a permanent slave, as inherently evil.

Quite the opposite.

They use the term slave to positively describe their relationship with Christ.

This does not mean they endorsed the horrifying aspects of slavery in their day. They did not. But they did not seem to find the basic idea of belonging to another as a servant or slave to be inherently part of that horror.

That distinction matters. The New Testament condemns exploitation, injustice, kidnapping, and mistreatment while still using slavery language positively for the Christian’s relationship to Christ.

Where That Leaves Us

Does the Bible endorse slavery? Yes, the Bible authorizes slavery. But was slavery in the Bible the same as American slavery? The slavery authorized in the Bible was governed by radically different moral and legal conditions from the oppressive systems of slavery we have examined throughout history. And that difference really, really matters.

God does not appear averse to the idea of ownership over a human being. The true question is whether God’s lack of aversion to that ownership violates His good character.

We have to assume it does not.

We can have a whole philosophical debate about that. We can write books and articles about it. I could dedicate my entire blog to this subject. But in the end, while a nonbeliever may find reason to question the goodness of God, the Christian must consider a different path when faced with unresolved questions.

Faith.

Can we trust the Weaver of the Great Tapestry when our knowledge is limited?

Yes, we can.

Because I know God is good, I know His decisions are good. I know His evaluations of a situation or philosophical position are good. So if God has no problem with one human being holding a form of ownership over another human being, then I have to question whether I should either.


All Scripture quotations are from the New International Version (NIV).  

Similar Posts